Duryea's Lobster Deck

A century-old Fort Pond Bay lobster shack turned high-end seafood deck, still serving its famous lobster roll alongside a raw bar of local oysters.

Duryea's traces back to a Tuthill Road fish market and wholesale lobster pound that fed Montauk for decades before a 2014 sale brought teak furniture, banquette seating, and a Mediterranean-leaning menu to the deck. The kitchen keeps the classics that built its reputation — chilled and steamed lobster, a cobb salad piled with crab and shrimp, a buttered lobster roll — while the setting itself, with yachts moored just off the dock and Fort Pond Bay stretching out behind the tables, remains the real draw at sunset.

Best for: Sunset dinners and waterfront lobster feasts with a boat-in crowd