Skip to content
TrendEat

City guide

The best of Montauk

Our curated pick of the finest restaurants, cocktail bars, and cafés in Montauk — chosen for cuisine, design, and experience, and led by the TrendEat Score.

Explore MontaukWhat’s newBy moodOn the map
Best RestaurantsBest Seafood restaurantsBest American restaurantsBest Italian restaurantsBest Mediterranean restaurantsAll guides →
Talya Montauk

Talya Montauk

$$$
Montauk, New York4.8(535)
Bird on the Roof

Bird on the Roof

$$
Montauk, New York4.6(564)
Alimentari Beach Montauk

Alimentari Beach Montauk

$$
Montauk, New York4.5(464)
The Beach Club at Gurney's Montauk

The Beach Club at Gurney's Montauk

$$$
Montauk, New York4.6(133)
Rooted

Rooted

$$$
Montauk, New York4.5(77)
Barlume Beach Restaurant

Barlume Beach Restaurant

$$$
Ditch Plains, Montauk4.5(64)
Mary Lou's Montauk
TrendEat Pick

Mary Lou's Montauk

$$$
Montauk, New York3.9(87)
Ditch Witch

Ditch Witch

$
Ditch Plains, Montauk4.2(70)
Alba Spiaggia

Alba Spiaggia

$$$
Montauk, New York4.4(21)
The Surf Lodge
TrendEat Pick

The Surf Lodge

$$$
Montauk, New York3.5(594)
Duryea's Lobster Deck

Duryea's Lobster Deck

$$$$
Fort Pond Bay, Montauk, Montauk

Get the best of Montauk, quietly

New guides and openings in Montauk, straight to your inbox. No spam, ever.