Montauk guide

The best American restaurants in Montauk

5 spots worth your time, hand-picked by our editors and grounded in real listings, never invented rankings.

♡

Restaurant

TrendEat Pick

Mary Lou's Montauk

$$$

Montauk

♡

Restaurant

TrendEat Pick

The Surf Lodge

$$$

Montauk

♡

Cocktail Bar · Restaurant

Bird on the Roof

$$

Montauk

♡

Restaurant

Ditch Witch

$

Ditch Plains, Montauk

♡

Restaurant

The Beach Club at Gurney's Montauk

$$$

Montauk, Ocean Beachfront (Gurney's Resort), Montauk

Guides appear once at least 3 real listings back them, so a list is never padded out.